Decades after their rumored fling and public feud, Eminem and Mariah Carey are still unexpectedly linked. A resurfaced claim has shocked fans: Eminem allegedly wanted Mariah Carey to play his mother in the 2002 semi-autobiographical film 8 Mile. The surprising casting idea has reignited conversations around the rapper’s long-standing fixation with the pop diva—and raised new questions about why he just can’t seem to let her go.
The Unexpected Casting Choice
According to reports and long-time collaborators, Eminem briefly floated the idea of having Mariah Carey portray his mother in 8 Mile. The film, which tells a fictionalized version of Eminem’s own troubled rise to fame, features a complicated and emotionally charged mother-son dynamic. Casting Mariah in that role would’ve been a major—and frankly bizarre—move, considering their messy history and Eminem’s repeated lyrical jabs aimed at her.
Though the idea never made it past the brainstorming stage, the fact that it was even considered says a lot.
A Timeline of the Eminem–Mariah Feud
Their relationship, or lack thereof, has been one of the most talked-about non-romances in music history.
- Early 2000s: Eminem claims they dated. Mariah denies it.
- 2002–2009: Eminem repeatedly references Mariah in lyrics, often mocking or vilifying her.
- 2009: Mariah drops “Obsessed,” a not-so-subtle clapback. Eminem responds with “The Warning,” a diss track laced with explicit threats and alleged voicemails.
- 2020: He brings her up again—this time in a feature with Fat Joe—reminding fans the obsession isn’t over.
So why does he keep circling back?
Control, Ego, and Public Narrative
Eminem has built much of his career on controversial storytelling and personal vendettas. His fixation with Mariah may have started as romantic rejection—but over time, it became a power struggle. She denied their past, refused to play along, and publicly embarrassed him. For someone as image-conscious and combative as Eminem, that kind of narrative loss may feel intolerable.
Having Mariah portray his mother would’ve flipped the script—literally. It’s a psychological power play: a way to reduce her to a supporting role in his story.
Mariah’s Silence Speaks Volumes
Mariah Carey has rarely responded directly to Eminem in recent years, choosing instead to focus on her legacy as a chart-topping icon and memoirist. Her silence has only intensified public fascination with the one-sided feud, and perhaps that’s what truly fuels Eminem’s lingering obsession: the refusal to be seen, heard, or controlled on his terms.
Conclusion:
Whether it was a serious casting idea or just an ego-driven fantasy, Eminem wanting Mariah Carey to play his mom in 8 Mile is proof that he still can’t get her out of his head. Nearly two decades later, the “obsessed” label might apply more to him than to her.
Follow MEFeater for more pop culture deep dives and music news!
Do you think Eminem ever really moved on from Mariah—or is he still writing chapters in a story she ended long ago? Drop your thoughts in the comments.
Follow MEFeater on Twitter, Instagram, Facebook, and Pinterest for the latest headline news.
